9 Best Myths and Urban Legends in Michigan

Michigan is brimming with spooky stories and terrifying tales. Whether you’re warming up at a bonfire with your friends or trying to spook your younger sibling, these 10 myths and urban legends are stories to be told. Read on if you dare. 

1. Creepy clown sightings

Throughout the United States in 2016, there were sightings of individuals—sometimes groups of them—dressed as clowns and chasing, menacing, or just plain old creeping out the public. Michigan is no exception, a cursory search reveals a pair of teenagers finding a clown around Flint near the Kimberly Oaks home, as well as a report of a clown near Big Rapids, a clowny trio in Dearborn, and one arrested in Kalamazoo near Loy Norrix school. 

2. Squirrel warfare

Michigan is full of squirrels, but the question is, which of these squirrels are evil? Michigan is one of a handful of places in the United States where black squirrels can be found, reports note, but many consider these little guys to be harbingers of evil. However, the black squirrel may not be Michigan's true evil at all, as Kellogg's cereal founder W.K. Kellogg was said to have imported black squirrels into Michigan. This wasn't a curse on the state, but rather, it was a measure to counter what Kellogg apparently considered the real evil: red squirrels, which were overpopulating his company’s grounds. So, which squirrel is the true monster?

3. Jimmy Hoffa mystery

Jimmy Hoffa's disappearance is one of the longest-running mysteries around, and Michigan is home to at least a couple potential sites of his burial. Hoffa was an American labor union leader who disappeared in July of 1975. A northwest Detroit home may have played host to Hoffa's murder, some reports note, and a Milford Township horse farm may have been his burial site. Of course, there are a lot of mysterious sites for Hoffa's death and/or burial, but Michigan has its share of possibilities.

4. Move over Bermuda, It's the Michigan Triangle

Lake Michigan travelers be warned, because there's a chunk of the lake that actually has similar properties to the legendary Bermuda Triangle. Connecting Ludington, Manitowoc and Benton Harbor, this large chunk covers almost one-third of the lake's surface. That particular area demonstrates several unusual phenomena, including ships and planes gone missing over the area. Given that the area is substantially broad and mostly water, this isn't too surprising if tragic. Reports of unusual storms over the region, however, are more readily witnessed. With over 1,000 known wrecks, and around 150 of them gone without a trace, there may be something going on under Lake Michigan's expansive waters.

5. The Landmark Inn's most famous guest may have never left

In Marquette, there's a small hotel known as the Landmark Inn that's actually quite a landmark in its own right. The hotel once played host to none other than legendary pilot Amelia Earhart, and not long before her death, either. Now, reports suggest she returns to Room 502, where guests have spotted flickering lights and have heard unusual noises coming from under the bed.

6. Michigan's Red Dwarf

The Red Dwarf, also known as the "Nain Rouge," is said to be a part of Detroit's history going back to its founding. While original legends consider it to be a protector of the city, updates now consider the Red Dwarf to be a darker sign. The dwarf reportedly attacked one of Detroit's first settlers, Antoine de la Mothe Cadillac, who lost his fortune not long after the encounter. Additionally, it was seen the day before the 1967 riots in Detroit and ahead of the city's worst ice storm in 1976. Now, the city hosts a controversial expulsion ceremony, known as the Marche du Nain Rouge, which features a parade and the destruction of an effigy.

7. Cryptids aplenty

Not only is Michigan home to the Dogman, an alleged seven-foot-tall, man-canine hybrid. It turns out that this was just part of the list, as a Bigfoot sighting was recorded between Kalamazoo County towns Fulton and Climax, and two lake monsters are a part of the package, including Pressie near Ontonogon's Porcupine Mountains and the Dewey Lake Monster near Dowagiac. While Pressie is said to be more of a "sea serpent," the Dewey Lake Monster is seen around the lake and a long stretch of unpaved road known as Dewey Lake Street.

8. Michigan is for lovers?

Not all urban legends are of the creepy variety, as the state has three separate legends involving young lovers and unexpected kissing locations. At Michigan State University, those who kiss in the shadow of Beaumont Tower—particularly at midnight exactly—are fated to marry each other. A similar sentiment is expressed for the Engineering Arch at the University of Michigan as well as the Warriner Hall Seal at Central Michigan University. The Central story has a bit of a darker twist to it: Two young lovers were set to elope, and planned to meet there that night before leaving. The boy's car broke down on the way, and left him several hours late. A Michigan night is seldom warm, and the waiting young lady froze to death, waiting for her love to arrive. In utter heartbreak, the boy kissed the frozen remains, and died himself. Now, the duo provides an otherworldly blessing to those who meet as they once intended.

9. Be sure you can swim when visiting Mackinac Island

Why? Because you may want a quick way off Mackinac Island. While Mackinac is known for its fudge, its nigh-total lack of cars and the Grand Hotel, it is also known as one of the state's biggest nexus points for hauntings. The Grand Hotel was built over the original military post's cemetery, and even the legendary TAPS team from Ghost Hunters took on Fort Mackinac. Though they didn't expressly call it "haunted," several electronic voice phenomena were taken, and the team was said to be impressed. That's just the start, though, as other places like the Bogan Lane Inn are haunted, and even the island's original inhabitants, the Anishinaabe tribes, considered it home to Gitche Manitou, or the "Great Spirit."

Share your favorites!
Michigan Search
Best Things To Do Near You
Best Things To Do Near You
May
26

Alma Highland Festival

5:30 PM
Alma High School, Alma, MI
Learn More
May
27

Open Studio

10:00 AM
Creative 360, Midland, MI
Learn More
May
27

Memorial Day Weekend

5:00 PM
Lake of Dreams Campground, Merrill, MI
Learn More
May
27

Steve Martin

8:00 PM
Soaring Eagle Casino, Mount Pleasant, MI
Learn More
May
27

Steve Martin

8:00 PM
Soaring Eagle Casino & Resort, Mount Pleasant, MI
Learn More
May
28

Memorial Day Pancake Breakfast

8:00 AM
Morton Township Fire Rescue, Stanwood, MI
Learn More
May
28

Memorial Day Weekend

10:00 AM
Lake of Dreams Campground, Merrill, MI
Learn More
Show More
Best Places To Go Near You
Best Places To Go Near You
Island Park, Mount Pleasant, MI
Hours of Operation: Dawn to Dusk, not outside the hours of 8:00 a.m. - 10:30 p.m. A special thanks to the following for their contributions t... Read More
1989 West Pine River Road, Breckenridge, MI
River Ridge Campgrounds is a modern family-operated campground, centrally located in the Tri-City area. There are beautiful shady sites along the s... Read More
8614 North US 127, Saint Johns, MI
Our founders John and Carolyn Beck purchased the “family farm” from John’s parents in the early 1970′s. Originally run as a... Read More
P.O. Box 1, Stanton, MI
Stanton Old Fashioned Days is Stanton's yearly city celebration. It takes place annually on the second weekend in August. The festival includes: a ... Read More
7573 Hayes Road, Fenwick, MI
About Us: Local dirt track located between Ionia and Crystal, we race every Friday night at 8m. Regular car classes are late models, modifieds, pr... Read More
911 Bills Lane, Saint Johns, MI
Ever play video games like: Call of Duty, Halo or Medal of Honor? Mobile Laser Kombat is the same type of gaming experience, only you are the real ... Read More
3131 South Old U.S. 27, Saint Johns, MI
Andy Todosciuk has been serving the local mid-Michigan community for 39 years as a retailer. It all began with a roadside stand in 1978. Andy has ... Read More
1 Golfside Drive, Midland, MI
Inline Skates & Skateboards Located in Chippewassee Park, just over the Tridge in downtown Midland you can find Trilogy Skate Park. This 15,00... Read More
12633 Beaver Road, Saint Charles, MI
Mission:To educate, lead and serve youth and adults through a positive learning environment providing hands-on experiences in a natural setting. Read More
506 West Main Street, Dewitt, MI
Our Mission: Encourage preservation of our natural environment through ecological photography education. Our Vision: Offer year-round opportunitie... Read More
85 West Wheeler Road, Auburn, MI
Bring the family out for Friday night fun to the newly renovated Tri-City Motor Speedway for stock car racing. The 3/8 mile clay oval track provide... Read More
405 South Washington Street, Owosso, MI
Steam Railroading Institute History How we got here... The Steam Railroading Institute, dedicated to educating the public about steam-era railroad ... Read More
Select a Michigan town to find
the Best Things-To-Do and Places To Go around you
Crawford County